LLMs Are Your New Brand Reps - But You Didn't Hire Them

Imagine waking up to discover that thousands of sales representatives and customer service agents have been actively representing your brand worldwide, 24/7, completely without your knowledge or training. Inconceivable just a few years ago, this is essentially the reality for brands in 2025. Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4.5, Google's Gemini, Anthropic's Claude, and search-integrated AI like Perplexity have effectively become unofficial, autonomous brand representatives.

They recommend (or don't recommend) your products, answer detailed questions about your company history and values, and even attempt to provide basic customer support – all based on the vast, complex web of information they were trained on or can retrieve. And here’s the crux of the challenge: you never hired them, trained them on your brand guidelines, or briefed them on your latest offerings. This unavoidable reality raises an urgent question for CMOs and brand leaders: How do we manage our brand's representation when LLMs are constantly speaking on our behalf? Adopting a proactive Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) strategy is no longer optional; it's essential.

LLMs in the Wild: The Unsolicited Brand Ambassador

• How LLMs Act as Brand Reps: When a user asks an LLM, "What’s the best running shoe for marathon training?" and it replies, "Based on expert reviews and user feedback, I'd recommend Brand X’s Ultraboost series for its superior cushioning and proven durability," that AI has just acted as a highly influential product representative for Brand X. Similarly, if someone inputs, "I'm having trouble connecting my Acme smart thermostat to Wi-Fi," and the AI responds with troubleshooting steps (correct or incorrect) or even offers a generic apology seemingly on behalf of Acme – it's performing unsolicited customer support.
• Unprecedented Scale and Impact: A single LLM platform can interact with millions, even billions, of users globally. Even if only a minuscule fraction of those interactions involves your brand, the cumulative impact on customer perception can exceed that of your entire human sales or support teams. Furthermore, because LLMs often generate responses with a tone of confidence and apparent authority, users frequently accept their statements as objective truth or expert opinion. They function like word-of-mouth recommendations on an unprecedented scale, often perceived as more neutral than advertising.
• You Didn’t Hire Them, You Can’t Fire Them: Brands cannot simply "turn off" these AI brand reps operating on public platforms like ChatGPT, Gemini, or Copilot. They exist independently and will continue to synthesize and share information about your brand based on the data available to them. Ignoring this phenomenon is not a viable strategy. The only effective approach is to actively work to influence what information they access and how they interpret it – the core task of AEO.

The Risks of Unmanaged AI Brand Reps

Allowing these powerful, untrained LLMs to represent your brand without oversight introduces significant risks:

1. Misinformation & Hallucination: LLMs are known to make mistakes. They might confidently state incorrect facts (e.g., wrong product specifications, outdated pricing, inaccurate company history) or entirely "hallucinate" information that sounds plausible but is false (e.g., fabricating features, misattributing quotes to your CEO, or incorrectly stating affiliations). If these inaccuracies involve your brand, especially regarding sensitive areas like safety or financials, the reputational damage can be severe.
2. Propagation of Outdated Information: LLMs relying solely on older training data won't be aware of your latest product launches, rebranding efforts, recent acquisitions, or corrected information. They may present an outdated picture of your company, making your brand appear stagnant, unresponsive, or less credible than competitors who have ensured their current information is AI-accessible.
3. Brand Tone and Personality Mismatch: Your brand might cultivate a specific personality – perhaps innovative and edgy, or warm and supportive. An LLM, generating text based on statistical patterns, might respond to queries about your brand in a generic, dry, or even contradictory tone, diluting your carefully crafted brand identity in countless interactions.
4. Inherent Biases and Uneven Representation: While aiming for neutrality, LLM outputs can reflect biases present in their training data. If your competitor received disproportionately more online coverage, the AI might mention them more frequently, effectively siphoning attention. If prevailing sentiment about your industry is negative, the AI might inadvertently cast your brand in that same light. Different AI models can also exhibit different biases, meaning users might receive varying (and potentially unfair) representations depending on the platform they use.
5. Emerging Legal and Ethical Quandaries: The legal landscape surrounding AI-generated content is still evolving. Instances of AI generating defamatory statements have occurred. If an LLM disseminates harmful falsehoods about your brand, recourse is currently complex. Furthermore, if an AI provides incorrect advice regarding the use of your product leading to harm, questions of liability could arise. Proactive management is crucial in this uncertain environment.

Embracing, Educating, and Influencing Your AI Reps: An AEO Approach

Managing these autonomous brand reps requires a strategic, ongoing effort grounded in AEO principles:

1. Embrace the Reality: The first step is acceptance. LLMs are part of your brand ecosystem now. Hope is not a strategy; customers will use AI to learn about you. Frame this not just as a risk, but as an opportunity to shape the narrative at scale if managed correctly.
2. "Educate" the AI (Indirectly but Intentionally): While you can't directly "train" large public LLMs like ChatGPT or Gemini in the traditional sense, you can significantly influence the information they access and prioritize. This involves:
   • High-Quality Information Diet: Consistently publishing clear, accurate, factual, and well-structured content about your brand across your owned channels (website, blog) and working to ensure accuracy on key third-party platforms (review sites, directories, news outlets, relevant wikis). This is the primary way to "educate" external AIs.
   • Internal Expertise: Designate an internal team or point person responsible for "AI Brand Representation" – a role blending PR, SEO, content strategy, and digital analytics. Their job is continuous monitoring, analysis, and strategic content/data adjustments based on how AI is portraying the brand. This team must also educate internal marketing and comms teams to consider AI interpretation when crafting messages.
3. Influence through Consistency and Clarity: LLMs are powerful pattern-recognition machines. The more consistent your brand messaging, factual data (especially when using structured data/Schema.org), and core narrative are across all digital touchpoints, the more likely AI models are to reflect that consistent picture accurately. Develop a clear brand knowledge graph or similar structured repository of canonical facts to ensure internal alignment and provide a reliable source for AI systems. Mixed messages online lead to muddled AI outputs.

Case Analogy: The Global Hotel Concierge Network:

Think of public LLMs as a vast, interconnected network of millions of hotel concierges. Guests (users) constantly ask them for recommendations ("best local restaurants/products") or information ("tell me about nearby attractions/your company"). You can't personally train every concierge, but you can influence them by ensuring your establishment (brand) has excellent public reviews, provides clear and accessible information (like menus/product specs online), potentially earns accolades they're aware of (industry awards mentioned in sources they trust), and maintains a positive reputation in the local information ecosystem. Influencing LLMs requires a similar strategy: manage your online reputation, provide clear and structured information, and build authority through credible third-party validation.

Conclusion: A New Frontier Requiring Active Brand Management

You didn't explicitly hire LLMs like GPT-4.5 or Gemini as your brand representatives, but they are performing that function daily, at scale. Ignoring them is ceding control of your brand narrative to algorithms. Modern brand management, therefore, must extend to proactively nurturing the information environment these AI systems learn from. This is the essence of Answer Engine Optimization (AEO).

This new frontier requires vigilance and adaptation but also presents immense opportunities. Brands that implement robust AEO strategies – embracing monitoring, ensuring data accuracy and consistency, and actively shaping their narrative across the digital ecosystem – can transform these "unhired reps" into powerful, albeit indirect, allies. They can ensure that when AI speaks about their brand, it does so accurately, positively, and effectively, amplifying their reach and reinforcing trust.

Don't forget to continuously listen through AI Visibility Monitoring tools and processes. Even the most sophisticated AI reps operate based on the data they see, and that data landscape is constantly changing. Your role as brand leader is to be the vigilant manager, guiding the narrative and ensuring your unofficial AI team represents you well.

‍